I have worked with other editors both before and after this incident and often they say things about my writing that deep down I know are true. But I haven't been able to fix the problem because either I haven't wanted to admit the truth or I have been standing too close to know how to fix it. Editors bring unbiased eyes to a manuscript where their sole concern is the quality of the writing not the fragility of the author's ego. This is what you want in an editor, although it can be painful. I feel very ambivalent when I receive work back from an editor. I can't wait to read what they think but I dread all the alterations they suggest.
At most conferences there are lots of opportunities to talk to editors, publishers, consultants and peers about your work. Although this may be a scary thing to do, to put your work in the public arena, it is also very beneficial and helpful. It will make for a better manuscript and turn you into a better writer, especially if editors keep correcting the same mistakes (I speak from experience!).
At the upcoming Christian Writers Conference the following people are available for appointments:
If you are attending the conference (or considering attending) and interested in making an appointment with a particular editor or publisher, forms are available via this link (scroll down to Appointments): Conference Appointments
*****
Thanks for sharing your experiences with editors Susan. I've experienced both sides of the coin in that I've critiqued other people's manuscripts and I've also had mine critiqued. I've learned so much from being on both sides of the fence. When you give someone a manuscript that you think is pretty good and it comes back covered in red pen or 'track changes', you can think 'Oh no, it must be terrible'. But I know when I've sat down and tried to look at the comments objectively, I've realised that I still have a lot to learn. I don't think we ever stop learning, but we can all keep improving. Thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeleteThanks Nola and yes, we are always looking for better ways of expressing the message we feel God has put on our hearts.
DeleteThanks, Susan. I think you have made the need for good editing really clear from your own experience. And what a great line-up of editors/publishers for authors to choose from at the Writers' Conference! I have encouraged quite a few new authors I know to come to the conference and I am hoping some of them at least will take advantage of a consultation with an editor as well.
ReplyDeleteThanks Jo-Anne for getting the word out about the conference. It is indeed a great opportunity to get some feedback.
DeleteI hope many people take advantage of the great number of experienced people available to consult with in October. How great, that they are all offering their time at the same venue.
ReplyDeleteThanks Paula, I hope so too. I find face to face appointments a great way to get to know an editor/publisher and whether they are going to be a good 'fit'.
DeleteHow lovely and helpful this editor was for you, Susan. What a blessing!
ReplyDeleteYes indeed!
Delete